Our Flavors

Enjoy a wide variety of treats at Sweet Mary’s. From delicious ice creams to non-dairy, sorbet and hard serve yogurt flavors, to fresh-made ice cream sandwiches and soda floats, to beautiful specialty sundaes and puppy pies especially for your best buddy, Mary’s offers something for everyone!  Some of our flavors change based on season and availability. Call to confirm availability.

Cones and Cups

Enjoy any of our flavors in a cup or on a cake, sugar or waffle cone. Mini size cake cones available for little appetites, as well as gluten-free cake and sugar cones.


Thick and creamy shakes, made with any of our hard serve or soft serve ice creams.


Delicious, creamy Turner’s Soft Serve Ice Cream blended with your choice of candy, fruit, nuts, brownies or cookies.

Soda Floats

Enjoy an old-fashioned root beer, Coca Cola, crème soda or cherry soda float, made with your choice of ice cream.

Specialty Sundaes

Sweet Mary’s offers brownie sundaes, banana splits, strawberry shortcake and praline pecan balls for a special treat! For smaller appetites, small, medium and large sundae sizes are available with your choice of ice cream and toppings.

Sweet Slush

In favorite flavors of cherry, grape, lime or raspberry.

Sweetie Pies

Mary’s own special treat! An ice cream sandwich made with your choice of hard serve ice cream and your choice of cookie. Supplied by both Dudt and Oakmont bakeries, choose chocolate chip, chocolate walnut, sugar cookie, peanut butter or snickerdoodle cookies. (Cookie choices may vary depending on availability.) Choose a delicious ice cream to go between your cookies and finish it off with mini chocolate chips, or coconut edging. Mmmmm! Very sweet!

Puppy Pies

Don’t forget your best four-legged friend when you come to Mary’s! Puppy pies are Turner Dairy Soft Serve vanilla ice cream with two biscuits.

Soda, iced tea, bottled water, and fresh brewed hot coffee and tea are also available.

Not all flavors available at all times. Please call to confirm availability.

Real Dairy Ice Cream

Vanilla Bean

Captain’s Chocolate


Butter Pecan

Butterscotch Bomb

Salty Caramel Peanut

Stellar Coffee

Raspberry Truffle

Toasted Coconut

Caramel Caribou

Cookies N Cream

Special Praline

Strawberry Cheesecake

Banana Strawberry

Chocolate Chip


Key Lime Pie


Cotton Candy

Bear Claw

Apple Strudel

Carrot Cake


Mint Moose Tracks

Midnight Chocolate

Coffee Club

Purple Daze

Black Cherry

Cookie Dough

Black Raspberry

Cherries and Cream

“C” is for Cookie

Peanut Butter Fudge

Peanut Butter Cup

Non Dairy Ice Cream

Coconut Almond Fudge

Peanut Butter Fudge

Vanilla Bean

No Sugar Added Ice Cream

Carmel Pecan Twist

Red Raspberry Cheesecake

Butter Pecan


Chocolate Chip

Amaretto Almond







Key Lime


Hard Pack Yogurt

Black Cherry

Kahlua Almond Fudge

Cookies and Cream


Cherry Vanilla

Real Soft Serve Ice Cream from Local Turner Dairy

Vanilla Chocolate